Judge Orders WordPress to Stop Blocking WP Engine Access

WP Engine vs. Automattic: A Major Legal Battle in the WordPress Community

The ongoing legal dispute between WP Engine and Automattic has taken a significant turn. Recently, a California District Court judge granted WP Engine a preliminary injunction against Automattic, WordPress' parent company, thereby stopping the latter from blocking WP Engine's access to vital WordPress.org resources and its plugins.

The Background of the Case

WP Engine, a leading third-party WordPress hosting platform, filed a lawsuit alleging that Automattic, led by CEO Matt Mullenweg, was causing "multiple forms of immediate irreparable harm." The lawsuit specifically targeted Mullenweg and accused him of restricting WP Engine's access to WordPress.org resources.

Mullenweg's Campaign Against WP Engine

This legal action follows a public campaign waged by Mullenweg in September. He accused WP Engine of misusing WordPress trademarks and criticized the service for not contributing sufficiently to the WordPress community. Automattic proceeded to block WP Engine’s access to WordPress.org’s servers and even took control of essential components like WP Engine’s ACF Plugin.

Judge's Findings

Judge Araceli Martínez-Olguín found substantial merit in WP Engine’s claims, stating that Automattic’s actions could potentially harm WP Engine’s business relationships. The judge remarked that Mullenweg's behavior appeared to be aimed at inducing breaches or disruptions in WP Engine's operations.

Automattic's Defense

In response, Automattic argued that WP Engine's reliance on WordPress.org to power its business was self-imposed. However, the judge dismissed this defense, citing that Automattic's targeted actions against WP Engine could not be overlooked.

Consequences of the Ruling

The ruling affirmed that WP Engine is likely to suffer irreparable harm without injunctive relief, which could also adversely affect other members of the WordPress community. As part of the preliminary injunction, Automattic must dismantle a specific site feature designed to track outgoing WP Engine customers and eliminate a verification checkbox that asked WordPress users to confirm they are not affiliated with WP Engine during login.

Community Reactions

The verdict has sparked a variety of reactions within the WordPress community, with many observing the impact of this legal battle on the larger ecosystem. Both WP Engine and Automattic have been approached for comments, but responses have yet to be received.

Conclusion

This preliminary injunction marks a crucial moment in the ongoing struggle between WP Engine and Automattic. As both parties navigate this complex legal landscape, the judgment emphasizes the various aspects of competition, trademark integrity, and community contributions within the WordPress ecosystem.

For further reading, check out related articles on this dispute: