Roblox Faces New York's Kids Online Safety Legislation: A Growing Concern

The Growing Concern for Kids' Online Safety in New York

As online platforms continue to evolve, so do the concerns about children's safety in the digital world. New York State Senator Andrew Gounardes (D) is at the forefront of advocating for kids' online safety, having sponsored significant laws like the Stop Addictive Feeds Exploitation (SAFE) for Kids Act and the New York Child Data Protection Act, both of which Governor Kathy Hochul signed earlier this year. However, a question from parents regarding the popular gaming platform Roblox has pushed the conversation further: "Does it cover Roblox?" This query highlights the gaps that exist in current regulations, which primarily focus on traditional social media platforms.

Introducing the New York Children’s Online Safety Act (NYCOSA)

Gounardes is responding to this concern with a new piece of legislation—the New York Children’s Online Safety Act (NYCOSA). This act is designed to regulate how minors communicate on various online social networks, aiming to enhance safety and privacy for young users.

Key Provisions of NYCOSA

• Profile Privacy: The legislation mandates that profiles created by minors on public or semi-public platforms must be private by default.
• Control for Parents: Parents of children under 13 will have the right to view and change privacy settings and approve friend requests.
• Restrictions on Communication: Minors will not be allowed to communicate with strangers unless they have first approved a friend request.
• Age Verification: All platforms used by minors must implement "commercially reasonable and technically feasible age verification" methods.
• Prohibition of 'Dark Patterns': The use of misleading design elements that push users to share more information or opt into features will be banned.

Why NYCOSA Matters

The NYCOSA builds on existing legislation and emphasizes the importance of protecting minors online. This act has been prompted not just by the rising popularity of platforms like Roblox but also increasing scrutiny over their safety practices. Gounardes stated, "We’re really focused on ensuring unconnected accounts are not able to direct message under-18 accounts without a friend request being approved first," emphasizing the need for strict communication policies.

Challenges with Age Verification

Age verification poses a significant challenge. While robust systems may require government-issued IDs, such methods can infringe upon privacy rights. The ongoing discourse within the judicial system surrounding age verification reflects a broader concern for personal data safety. NYCOSA advocates for age verification methods that do not compromise the privacy of young users.

Growing Awareness Among Lawmakers

Roblox, with its vast user base of children and teens, has largely avoided scrutiny compared to traditional social media platforms. Gounardes admits that many legislators are unfamiliar with the complexities of such platforms, noting how his understanding was shaped by older technologies like consoles. However, he warns that this ignorance can have serious consequences, especially as child predators find ways to exploit less monitored spaces online.

Recent Developments in Platform Policies

Amid mounting regulatory pressures, platforms like Roblox and Meta's Instagram are taking steps to address these concerns voluntarily. Roblox recently announced it will prohibit private messaging for users under 13 outside of games and requires parental permission for in-game messages. Meanwhile, Instagram has shifted to default-private accounts for users under 18.

Conclusion: A Call for Action

As Gounardes puts it, "Companies are feeling the heat," responding to public pressure and potential legislative changes. While these steps are promising, he believes they are insufficient. The NYCOSA aims to establish comprehensive regulations that ensure safer online experiences for children, reflecting society's growing recognition of the need for robust children's online safety laws.

Engage with Us!

What are your thoughts on the new regulations being proposed? Do you feel they are sufficient to protect your children online? Join the conversation and let us know your insights!