Scottish FA Confirms Validity of Rangers' Goal Against St Johnstone in League Cup

Controversial Refereeing Decision in Scottish League Cup Match

In a gripping encounter during the Scottish League Cup last Saturday, tension reigned as referee Matthew MacDermid faced scrutiny over his decision-making. The match between Rangers and St Johnstone saw a pivotal moment when Cyriel Dessers' shot found the net, raised questions regarding the officiating when MacDermid's whistle was not blown before the goal, despite a foul inquiry on Jack Sanders.

Meeting Between Scottish FA and St Johnstone

On Monday afternoon, the Scottish FA (SFA) convened with St Johnstone officials to discuss the controversial goal. The review confirmed that the goal by Dessers would stand, highlighting an important facet of the game - the role of VAR.

What Happened in the Match?

During the match, MacDermid called back the game after the incident to address the foul by Dessers on Sanders. Nevertheless, after scrutinizing the play through VAR, it was determined that the goal was valid. After the match, St Johnstone's manager, Craig Levein, expressed his players' confusion, suggesting they halted play under the impression that a foul had been awarded.

Manager Reactions

After the game, Levein was candid about his team's reaction to the officiating, stating:

"I thought it was a foul for us. I thought that Jack had been tripped by Dessers and that's why Jack was on the ground. Everybody stopped because of one or two things. Either they've stopped because they heard the whistle or they've seen the referee giving us a free-kick."

Despite the loss, Levein urged for transparency from the referee about the decision, hinting at a broader issue within officiating standards.

Rangers' Perspective

Conversely, Philippe Clement, Rangers' head coach, defended the usage of VAR, stating that it played a crucial role in ensuring justice in the match:

"I think this is then a good use of VAR from the referee, to have an idea in his head but not being sure, and to let the play go on until the game is stopped."

Clement acknowledged St Johnstone's frustration but maintained that the decision to allow the play to continue was justified.

Impacts on the League and Fan Reactions

This incident has caused an uproar among fans and analysts alike, bringing the effectiveness of refereeing and the use of technology in football into question. With the strong emotions surrounding this issue, it is evident that further discussions regarding officiating standards in Scottish football are necessary.

Looking Ahead

Moving forward, both clubs will seek to focus on their upcoming fixtures while the fallout from this game continues. Refereeing decisions remain a hot topic, and as the season progresses, the effectiveness of VAR will undoubtedly come under the spotlight in other matches.

Stay Updated with Scottish Football

Fans can stay updated with all the latest Scottish football news, fixtures, and results by visiting Sky Sports Scottish Football.

Join the Conversation

What are your thoughts on the use of VAR in Scottish football? Should referees be more accountable for their decisions? Join us in the comments below!