Partick Thistle Seeks Replay After Late Substitute Controversy Against Motherwell

Partick Thistle Demands Replay of League Cup Match Against Motherwell

In a dramatic turn of events, Partick Thistle has officially requested that their League Cup match against Motherwell be replayed, triggered by an unfortunate teamsheet mix-up that prevented them from making a timely substitution. The incident unfolded at Fir Park, where the Championship side aimed to bring on substitute Ricco Diack late in the game, only to be informed by the fourth official that his name wasn't listed among the substitutes.

The Events Leading to the Controversy

In an extensive statement, Partick Thistle clarified their side of the story, detailing the miscommunication that occurred during the match. They emphasized that they had submitted their lineup, including Diack as a substitute, through the COMET app by the deadline of 13:45. Despite following the proper channels, a breakdown in communication seemed to have led to this unfortunate event.

COMET App and the Teamsheet Issue

• Submitted line-up included 20 players, with Ricco Diack listed as the final substitute.
• Both teams confirmed their line-ups and had access to each other's matchday squads.
• An automated email featuring a PDF teamsheet was distributed, which should have included all substitute players.

The Fourth Official’s Error

Despite clear documentation, when Kris Doolan, Partick Thistle's manager, attempted to substitute Diack onto the field, the fourth official stated that Diack was not a registered substitute. This led to confusion and ultimately hampered the club's chances in the match.

Match Outcome and Implications

The game concluded in a 0-0 draw, with Partick Thistle securing two points in a penalty shootout. However, due to the mishap, they missed the opportunity to win all three points necessary for progression in the tournament. Despite securing two points, the result was still favorable for Motherwell, who advanced to face Kilmarnock in the next round.

The Call for Accountability in Match Official Procedures

Partick Thistle has lodged formal inquiries with the SPFL and the Scottish FA, seeking an explanation for the situation. In their statement, they highlighted the need for better accountability and efficiency in the match officials' processes, especially considering the introduction of new technology within the league:

"We find it impossible to believe that a screenshot can contain Motherwell's ninth substitute and not ours, with both players listed on the same text line."

Conclusion

The situation raises serious concerns regarding the newly implemented COMET system and its apparent lack of reliability during live match situations. As Partick Thistle looks to resolve this issue, it highlights a significant challenge facing clubs as modern technology and sport intertwine more closely.

The SPFL and SFA have been reached for comment, while Partick Thistle remains in hopes of having the matter thoroughly investigated.